Options to fix torn ACL: cadaver, patella, quad...?

I am having knee surgery soon for a torn ACL. I need to choose among the various options for replacement. My doctor said using a cadaver would be his choice as it's easier to recover, esp for women. Just wondering what others think or if they can share their experiences.

Autograft= from your body and less risk of rejection/infection
Allograft= from cadaver increased risk of rejection/infection over autograft

Patella tendon autograft: strongest of the grafts, but most painful in the first 1-2 wks. Usually have excellent outcomes and if you are a competitive athlete then this is the way to go.
Hamstring tendon autograft: fairly strong graft, not as painful as the patella tendon graft, but still painful in first 1-2 wks mostly.
Allograft: least strong and least painful to recover from, I am not a big fan of these if you are active.

Tags

　　Penile Disorders 　　Pelvic 　　Pediatrics 　　Peanut Allergy 　　Patient Rights 　　Paternity Testing 　　Patella 　　Parkinson Disease 　　Parenting 　　Parathyroid Disorders 　　Parasitic Diseases 　　Paranasal Sinus Cancer 　　Paralysis

Related information

Lateral knee discomfort just below the patella: what is it?

Ice it for 20 min on 20 min off several times a day for 2 days. If it still hunts see a doctor.

...

What kind of treatment for chondromalacia patella?

"Runner's knee" often affects young and otherwise healthy athletes. One of the most important treatments is to avoid the activity that caused the problem. Use of RICE - rest, ice,...

Can someone recommend a good vet surgeon to perform luxating patella surgery in southern california?

Look in the phone book, they all say they're good.

...

I tore my ACL 4+ yrs ago and had a patella graft. Since surgery I have had issues w/ the screw and retore ACL

If you want to be as active as you have been in the past then you must have the surgery to reconstruct your ACL. You need the stability in your knee that the ACL provides to do sports and to do tho...

What are the possible short term problems and the long term problems of a dislocated patella?

Short term: swelling, decreased strength in that leg, risk of dislocating the patella again. Long term: increased risk of dislocating the patella again due to stretching of the tissue surrounding ...

My daughter has been told she has cardio malaysia patella, what is this?

Are you sure it is "Cardio malaysia"? . I think it is Chondromalacia patellae. "Chondro" means Cartilage and "malacia" means like butter. Chondromalacia literal...

My hubby has to have knee surgery on the patella-tendon area,how long will it take to heal?

it could take anywhere from 4 months to 6 months to heal. It also depends on how much therapy he receives, and if he does it at home as well. Also the knee will never be the same again, it will pro...

Suggestions for a chihuahua that has a luxating patella - specifically exercises and treatments?

The best thing you can do for your little baby is get her to the vet before Monday. You need to have a complete diagnosis. I have used acupuncture on my dogs For all types of reasons including ba...